Sports commentators’ praise of particular athletes appears to have found new focus, previously centering around three-time Super Bowl Champion Patrick Mahomes but now also Brock Purdy. Purdy, known by some as Mr. Irrelevant due to being selected at last in NFL drafts, has received positive comments since leading his team all the way into Super Bowl LIII; but some fans found Kirk Herbstreit’s applause too overbearing during recent San Francisco 49ers-Seahawks game between 49ers and Seahawks matchup.
Purdy kicked off an extraordinary game by passing Deebo Samuel an impressive 76-yard pass, an attempt fraught with interception risk that instead resulted in a successful catch. Fans quickly turned their focus onto Herbstreit’s commentary and his selection of topics; many criticizing his choice to exclude Detroit Lions and Minnesota Vikings when discussing top NFC teams.
Herbstreit’s omission led to backlash, with fans suggesting he might be better suited to college football commentary. His focus on Purdy, especially, drew ire, with accusations of unwarranted praise despite the quarterback’s average performance.
Fans Critique Kirk Herbstreit’s Commentary Style
Discontent with Herbstreit’s broadcasting style was evident among fans, with some expressing their preference for hearing players over commentators. One particular bone of contention was Herbstreit’s alleged excessive praise of quarterbacks like Purdy, whom some viewers considered average at best.
Antholit’s failure to acknowledge Minnesota Vikings as top contender in NFC led to further discontent among fans, leading some to charge that he wasn’t up-to-speed with current NFL dynamics and dynamics.
Fan discontent stemmed not only from Herbstreit’s perceived bias but also his flawed game analysis, sparking debate on whether his commentary detracts from their viewing experience. Their call for him to alter his approach reflected an overall desire among them for more objective and inclusive sports commentary.